Playboy Jazz All-Stars Minus Don D.

Recently, I read a surprising statement somewhere (won’t say where) that Don Drummond was named to the Playboy All-Stars in 1964. This was the result of a readers’ poll that the magazine conducted annually. I was surprised, one, because I have never heard this or come across this before in my years of researching Don D., and two, because it would go against one of the major premises of my book, Don Drummond: The Genius and Tragedy of the World’s Greatest Trombonists, that a lack of recognition and acknowledgment of his talent, due to a variety of reasons that I outline in the book, contributed to his mental decline. So, I had to find out–was this true? Did I miss something this big? The answer was no.

I obtained a copy of that 1964 Playboy magazine, as well as one from 1965 in case the poll was taken in 1964 and published in 1965, and nada. Not one word about Don Drummond–not in the poll, nor in the excellent article (I was always told that Playboy had excellent articles! Ha ha) about the state of jazz that year in the U.S. and abroad. In fact, the articles give a snapshot, in a paragraph or two, of jazz worldwide and mention a few names, like Hugh Masekla, but no Jamaican at all. There is much editorial about the American jazz musicians overseas, and the jazz scene in Europe and Russia, but no Caribbean jazz is touched.

It is sad that I don’t see Don D’s name in these pages. He should have been here. He saw these lists, he saw the Downbeat articles, and it ate at him. His idols, J.J. Johnson and Kai Winding are here, and those he played with when they came to Jamaica, George Shearing and Dave Brubeck, are here too. Obviously I wanted to see that my argument was correct, that Don D was never treated fairly, but more than any selfish interest like that, I wanted to see that somewhere, sometime, Don Drummond was recognized. At least while he was alive.

Here are a few pages from those articles.


2 thoughts on “Playboy Jazz All-Stars Minus Don D.”

  1. Hello,

    I’ve just learned of your book on Drummond and look forward to reading it. I’ve read in several places that he had won a US jazz magazine poll — not Playboy but Downbeat, I believe. But I’ve just looked through their online poll archives and I see only one trombonist in the 50s and 60s: J.J. Johnson. It always seemed strange to me that American jazz lovers would have recognized his talent in that period, but I assumed the claim was true. Now I’m beginning to think it’s just one of those myths that took on a life of it’s own, like the “10% of your brain” thing. Do you have any more insight on this? Is there a grain of truth in it, or do you have any idea how this rumor got started?

    Thanks a lot and best regards

    Matt Parker


    1. Fascinating. I will look into the Downbeat as well, but I suspect that it is not true. And a myth. I know I would have come across it at some point, had he been in there, but I will try to find these original copies to see for myself. J.J. Johnson was Don D’s idol. I will let you know what I find–perhaps in a future blog post! Thanks for commenting–I love the dialogue. Respect, Heather


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s